Fiscal Note
Pursuant to this resolution the City will reduce budgeted property tax revenue (account # GN01-71111) by $28,059 to reflect the reimbursement of previously collected taxes. This action reduces the available fund balance but has no impact on the City's eligibility under the State Expenditure Restraint Program.
Title
Authorizing a refund in the amount of $28,058.76 for real property taxes for 2009, pursuant to a settlement of Cardinal Court, LLC v. City of Madison, Case No. 10CV3245
Body
The City of Madison was sued by Cardinal Court, LLC (“Cardinal Court”) for excessive tax, claiming the big box retail store they own located at 2301 East Springs Drive in the City of Madison was assessed at greater than fair market value. The City of Madison and Cardinal Court have tentatively reached an agreement to settle the dispute, subject to approval of the Common Council. Under the settlement, the City of Madison will refund the amount of $28,058.76 of 2009 property taxes from the $95,417.42 paid. This refund is based on a reduction in assessment from $4,395,000 to $3,100,000.
The tenant located in this property filed for bankruptcy in March of 2009 (Circuit City) and the real estate market took a downward turn shortly after the assessment date of January 1, 2009. The property now has a new tenant and lease in place and the City and Cardinal Court are not in dispute over the 2010 assessed value.
While property is to be assessed based on its value as of January 1st each year, the ensuing fall in commercial real estate value provides an argument to the property owner that those values had already started to fall as of January 1, 2009. In addition, at the time of the original claim for a refund, the property owner had not provided the City with a complete appraisal of the property. That appraisal is required for court proceedings. Upon review of the appraisal, the Assessor's opinion was that there was a reasonable chance a court would reduce the City's a...
Click here for full text