Fiscal Note
This proposed ordinance would establish a procedure whereby taverns could apply for a temporary hardship exemption from the City's smoking ban by submitting written proof of eligibility "subscribed and sworn to by a Certified Public Accountant." Any costs of preparing the required documentation and obtaining such CPA's "certification" of eligibility would be borne by the applicant. It is unclear if CPA firms would "subscribe and swear to" the cause of a revenue reduction, as required by the ordinance, and no reliable estimate is available as to how many applications might be submitted.
The City would incur costs only to the extent that staff or other resources were used to review or verify the accuracy of any exemption applications received. Because the ordinance provides for an automatic approval if no determination is made by the Comptroller within 30 days, and if no resources are committed to review or verify the legitimacy or accuracy of applications, then all applications would become approved without additional cost. Any substantive review of the accuracy of applications would, however, require an immediate staff or contracted service effort, to be completed prior to the expiration of the 30 day automatic approval period. No resources have been budgeted or are available for any significant enforcement related to this proposed ordinance amendment.
Title
Creating Section 23.05(7)(f) of the Madison General Ordinances to create a hardship exemption to the smoking regulations for taverns which meet certain requirements.
Body
DRAFTER'S ANALYSIS: This ordinance creates a hardship exemption to the smoking ban for taverns that experience a loss of gross receipts greater than ten percent (10%). The tavern must prove that the loss of revenue is due to compliance with the smoking ban and not some other circumstance unrelated to the smoking ban. This ordinance is not effective unless the Council also approves the smoking ban advisory r...
Click here for full text